Estimate Review and Approval Form Template
A quote is a commitment, and most bad ones are not caught because nobody looked at them together. This form puts cost, margin, risks and approvals on one page so a second person can review before release. Fill it in and export a PDF or Word copy.
Fill in
Estimate Review and Approval Form Template
Estimate Review and Approval
Quote: Q-26-1184 Customer: Northfield Aerostructures Part: BRK-4410 Rev C Estimator: R. Mehta Date: 2026-10-20
Financial summary
| Measure | Value |
|---|---|
| Total estimated cost | 48500 |
| Proposed price | 61200 |
| Gross margin percent | 20.8 |
| Policy minimum margin percent | 18 |
Risks and mitigations
Tight flatness tolerance may raise scrap. Aluminum plate price exposed for 30 days. Outside anodize lead time of 5 days not confirmed.
Review checks
| Check | Done | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Drawing revision and specs confirmed | ||
| Routing, setup and run times checked | ||
| Material and outside process prices current | ||
| Capacity and lead time confirmed | ||
| Assumptions and exclusions page attached |
Recommendation
Release as quoted
Approvals
This is a general internal form. Adapt thresholds to your own approval policy. If your quality system requires a contract review record, check that the fields cover what your standard asks for.
Flag low-margin quotes before they go out
Optional: see how margin checks can run against ERP estimates with human approval.
Optional. The tool and every export work without this. No spam.
How to use the form
The estimator fills the header and financial summary from the estimate, then writes the real risks, not generic ones. Reviewers tick the checks, add comments and sign. Route to the controller only if margin falls below policy. Keep the signed copy with the quote file. The decision field forces a clear recommendation: release, release with changes, escalate or decline. A declined quote with a reason is useful data too.
- Use the same form for every quote above a set value
- Attach the assumptions and exclusions page
- Record who approved, not just that it was approved
What the review should test
Reviewers should test the inputs that drive cost, not re-estimate everything. Are the setup and run times consistent with similar jobs? Are material and outside processing prices current? Is capacity real in the weeks promised? Does the margin meet policy after allowing for scrap and rework? Margin here is gross margin: (price minus cost) divided by price, which is not the same as markup on cost. Mixing the two is a common source of underpriced work.
Reading the margin
In the example, cost of 48,500 and price of 61,200 gives a gross margin of about 20.8 percent, above the 18 percent floor. That passes policy but the risk text matters: if scrap runs higher than assumed, the margin may fall below the floor. Reviewers should ask what scrap rate the estimate carries and whether the risk justifies a contingency or a higher price.
Common mistakes
Approving on margin alone, skipping capacity checks, relying on a verbal OK, and not storing the form where order entry can find it. For regulated customers, contract review may be a quality system requirement, so check your standard. Where possible, link the form number to the quote in the ERP so approvals are traceable when the job is audited or repriced.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who should approve a manufacturing quote?
At minimum the estimator and a second reviewer from operations, engineering or sales. Add a controller or manager when margin is below policy or value exceeds a set threshold. Define the thresholds in writing.
What is the difference between margin and markup?
Margin is profit divided by price. Markup is profit divided by cost. A 25 percent markup equals a 20 percent margin. Use one consistently on the form, and say which, so approvers read it correctly.
Is this form a contract review record?
It can support one, but check your quality standard for required content. Aerospace and automotive customers often expect documented review of requirements and capability. Add fields your standard requires.
Should declined quotes use the form?
Yes, a short entry. Recording why you declined, such as capacity or margin, helps you spot patterns in lost work and tune pricing and capacity planning.
If you want approvals routed and recorded inside your ERP, we can help set up a read-only margin check that flags quotes under policy before release.
Related Tools
Quote Assumptions and Exclusions Template
A fill-in page that states what a manufacturing quote includes, what it assumes and what it leaves out, ready to attach to the price.
Costing & FinanceTooling and NRE Amortization Quote Worksheet
Spread tooling, fixtures, gauges and engineering NRE across the quoted volume, net of what the customer pays up front.
Costing & FinanceJob Shop Quote Price, Margin and Markup Calculator
Turn cost inputs into a unit price at your target gross margin, including scrap, setup and outside processing, and see the markup it equals.
Costing & FinanceStandard Cost Change Request Template
Document why a standard cost is changing, the inventory revaluation impact and who approved it before the roll-up runs.
More Costing & Finance tools
See all- Manufacturing KPI Formula and Definitions Reference
- Manufacturing Cost Variance Types Reference
- Price, Volume and Cost Margin Variance Calculator
- Month End Reporting Readiness Checklist for Manufacturers
- OEE Improvement Value Calculator
- Improve OEE vs Buy a New Machine Calculator
- Six Sigma Project Savings Tracker Worksheet
- Should Cost Model Worksheet for Machined Parts
- Subcontract and Outside Processing Cost Worksheet
Keep exploring
Free tools
- Inventory Write-Off Approval Form TemplateA signed record for scrapping or writing off damaged, obsolete or lost inventory, with value, reason and approvals.
- Manufacturing Quote Review ChecklistA pre-send checklist covering scope, material, routing, outside processing, margin, risk and terms, with critical items flagged.
- Cost Estimating Review Checklist for Manufacturing QuotesA pre-submission review worksheet to catch missing operations, outside processing, scrap allowance, tooling and margin before a manufacturing quote goes out.
ERP fixes and how-tos
- How to Set Up Approval Routing in NetSuiteHow to configure NetSuite approval routing for purchase orders, vendor bills, and expense reports using native approval limits or SuiteFlow workflows.
- PO Not Released in SAP: Release Strategy, ME28 and ME29N FixesA SAP PO stays blocked when its release strategy is assigned but no one can release it. Check ME29N, release codes, ME28 and the workflow approver, step by step.
- How to Set Up an ION Workflow Approval for SyteLine Purchase OrdersHow to build an ION workflow approval for SyteLine purchase orders: trigger from a BOD, route to approvers by amount, and write the result back safely.
Guides
- AS9100 Contract Review Checklist for Aerospace Machine ShopsAS9100D contract review checklist for build-to-print machine shops: what to verify on every PO and RFQ, who signs, and the records an auditor expects.
- Prompt Injection Defense: An Enterprise ArchitecturePrompt injection defense architecture for enterprise AI: input and output filtering, least-privilege tool access, and human approval gates.
- AI for Casting RFQ and Drawing ReviewHow a private AI reads casting RFQ packages, prints and specs, flags alloy, NDT and tolerance risks, and drafts questions for the customer before you quote.
Integrations
- How to add Microsoft Teams to Epicor Vantage and Epicor 9Send Epicor Vantage and Epicor 9 approvals and alerts into Microsoft Teams with adaptive cards, Entra ID and BPM or Service Connect events.
- How to add Microsoft Teams to QAD Adaptive ERPAdd Microsoft Teams to QAD Adaptive ERP: adaptive cards for approvals, plant alerts, a Teams bot over QAD data, Entra ID sign-in and on-prem gateway design.